For the first time this season, when you walked out of GM Place after a Canucks game there was still just a little bit of daylight left. Unfortunately for the Vancouver Canucks, the tiny bit of light that their season may continue was extinguished at the hands of the Blackhawks on Tuesday night.
Like with any loss someone has to take the fall and while Mike Gillis and Alain Vigneault are unlikely to lose their jobs based on the Canucks second round defeat, the decisions they made may have unlitmately lead to the Canucks demise. Of course this isn’t to wash any of the blame away from the players because at the end of the day they are the ones playing the game, but for a team with such high expectations in a rabid hockey market one can wonder if they were given the best chance to succeed.
For a coach that put his trademark all over the Canucks 2007 playoff run by switching up his line combos on a shift-to-shift basis it was remarkable how uninterested Vigneault seemed in trying someone different when the Canucks appeared to be completely overmatched and out of sync on offense. Even though the Canucks forwards hadn’t scored a goal since late in game four, Vigneault stuck to his lines. It’s unexplainable as to why Mikael Samuelsson who led the first round of the playoffs in goals with seven was relegated to the third line with Kyle Wellwood and Michael Grabner. While Wellwood had a decent individual game, the trio had next to no chemistry together. While the offense continued to struggle, Vigneault left Pavol Demitra on the second line where he produced absolutely nothing positive.
Perhaps more proof that Vigneault was feeling the pressure and perhaps lost some faith in his team to get the job done was that fact that Demitra went from being a healthy scratch in game 4 to playing the last two games on the second line. If that wasn’t screaming desperation enough, perhaps Vigneault’s decision to put the stone-handed Jannik Hansen on that same second line instead of Samuelsson to start game 4. I’ve spent a large amount of time this season criticising Samuelsson’s play but it is confusing as to why one of the team’s best goal scorers isn’t being put into a position to succeed when the team needs goals the most.
The play of Pavol Demitra was also alarmingly poor in a time when the Canucks needed him the most. With Alex Edler injured, Vigneault insurance plan involved using Demitra at the point and like he was prone to do during the regular season, coughed up the puck trying to be too cute and shut the door on the Canucks season as the Hawks went up 3-0. It will also likely be a defining image for Canucks fans on a disappointing tenure in Canucks jersey. The disappointment of Demitra’s play will weigh heavily on General Manager Mike Gillis who made Demitra his first big and highest paid free agent signing, locking him in for two years and eight million dollars in 2007. Previously Dave Nonis got the boot for not making enough big moves and only re-signing current players on the roster. At this point it seems as if Gillis’ best moves to date are re-signing core players like the Sedins as well as Ryan Kesler. His additions to the team have been with very mixed results. Time will tell if Gillis’ commitment to strong drafting pays off.
The Canucks undermanned and overplayed defence will also be a sore spot on Gillis’ resume. When it was clear at the deadline that Willie Mitchell wasn’t going to be playing a role in the Canucks playoff drive and with no depth in the minor league, Gillis when out and got a bottom pairing defenseman in Andrew Alberts. There will be those that say that Gillis did the best with what he had to work with, but every concern that fans had with the defence came to life against the Chicago Blackhawks as the guys who were pushed out of their rolls and comfort zones due to injuries to players like Mitchell, Salo and Edler could not compete with the speed and skill of the ‘Hawks top players.
There were times when players such as Alberts and O’Brien were undisciplined and careless, but considering their skill level and where they should be on the depth chart, there wasn’t much more that could have been asked of them. Christian Ehrhoff appears to be a steal in the trade category for Gillis and while his free agent signings have been questionable he can take that deal with the cap shredding Sharks to the bank.
That, of course, brings us to Kevin Bieksa. It was quite a week for Bieksa who went from zero in game 4 to hero in game 5 and back to zero in game 6. It was Bieksa who somehow overskated the puck on the Blackhawks second goal and it also Bieksa who made terrible misread on Patrick Kane’s 4-1 goal that killed any hope of a Canucks comeback. With Edler injured and Salo at less than one hundred percent, the Canucks really needed Bieksa to step up his game but instead he turned in a dud. Perhaps injuries have set him back but for a guy who looked like he was going to turn into a star in the NHL, Bieksa is grossly overpaid at 3.5 million. I’m sure the Canucks would be happy to move that salary out to anyone that would take him.
It won’t go down as one of the memorable games and instead the Canucks and their fans will get another summer to wonder what went wrong, but at least we got to chant “balls of steel” in the first period.
Posted by Simon 






















































